Fire Truck Stop Sparks Fourth Amendment Questions for North Carolina Courts.

Drunk drivers pulled over at a police traffic stop are a common occurrence. Drunk drivers pulled over and arrested by private citizens are rare, but do still happen and are constitutional. A drunk driver pulled over by a fire truck makes for a constitutional case of first impression for North Carolina courts.

In a highly unusual incident in May 2011, University of North Carolina – Chapel Hill professor of history, Dorothy Hoogland Verkerk, was pulled over by a fire truck driven by Fire Lieutenant Gordon Shatley. According to Shatley, Verkerk was driving well below the speed limit, was swerving, had her hazard lights on and headlights off, and had a window open despite pouring rain. Shatley claims that he turned on the siren and fire truck lights to prevent other drivers from passing Verkerk’s vehicle. Shatley further claims that Verkerk’s car then struck a curb and Verkerk pulled over. Shatley ran over to Verkerk’s vehicle and asked her to park and to have someone pick her up. At this point, Verkerk sped away and Shatley called the police. Verkerk was pulled over by the police and arrested on suspicion of drunk driving.

Verkerk was convicted and sentenced to 30 days in jail, probation and community service. Verkerk has appealed her conviction on the ground that Shatley performed an unconstitutional traffic stop under the color of a government official, despite the fact that Shatley is not trained and not authorized to perform traffic stops. The appeals court partially agreed with Verkerk and remanded the case to the lower court to consider whether the initial actions by Shatley violated the Fourth Amendment prohibition on illegal searches and seizures – an issue that the lower court had not considered.

If the lower court finds that Shatley’s actions violated the Fourth Amendment, then the subsequent police stop and arrest were also unconstitutional under the Fruit of the Poisonous Tree doctrine and Verkerk’s conviction would likely be vacated.

Have you been injured by a drunk motorist’s negligent driving? Has a loved one been injured or even killed as a result of a drunk driving auto accident? If so, please call our expert Boston, MA law firm at 617-787-3700 right now to protect all of your legal rights and remedies.  Our Massachusetts personal injury attorneys, Massachusetts drunk driver personal injury attorneys and Boston, Massachusetts wrongful death accident attorneys are here 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, to assist you in recovering the personal injury damages or wrongful death damages you and your family deserve.

You can contact our specialist Boston personal injury lawyers, Massachusetts drunk driving personal injury lawyers and Boston, MA wrongful death lawyers at 617-787-3700 or at, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.

Please call our expert Massachusetts attorneys at 617-787-3700, 24/7. Your needs are our top priority!

This entry was posted in Boston Drunk Driving Accident Lawyer, Boston Negligence Lawyer, Boston Personal Injury Lawyer. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply